{"schemaVersion":"2.0.0","entries":[{"id":"selectra-2021-per-contract","comparator":"Selectra","supplier":"Fournisseur non divulgue","amountEur":52.6,"amountMinEur":52.6,"amountMaxEur":52.6,"amountUnit":"per_contract","amountNote":null,"currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2021,"evidenceSubject":"published_amount","evidenceType":"journalistic-investigation","sourceId":"complement-denquete-2024-03-07","sourceIds":["complement-denquete-2024-03-07"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.france.tv/france-2/complement-d-enquete/","sourceExcerpt":"Document interne Selectra cite par l'enquete: 52,60 euros par contrat signe.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Emission du 7 mars 2024","exactSourceStatus":"generic","legalStatus":"journalistic","confidence":"reported","reviewStatus":"needs_exact_source","legalReviewRequired":true,"proves":"Un montant publie pour une commission par contrat en 2021.","publishedAt":"2026-05-02T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Montant unique issu d'une source journalistique; ne pas extrapoler aux contrats actuels."},{"id":"papernest-2024-volume-tiered","comparator":"Papernest","supplier":"Fournisseur non divulgue","amountEur":null,"amountMinEur":null,"amountMaxEur":150,"amountUnit":"tiered","amountNote":"Grille par volume; montant haut publie autour de 150 EUR par contrat.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"published_amount","evidenceType":"journalistic-investigation","sourceId":"complement-denquete-2024-03-07","sourceIds":["complement-denquete-2024-03-07"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.france.tv/france-2/complement-d-enquete/","sourceExcerpt":"Grille Papernest consultee par l'enquete: commissions pouvant atteindre environ 150 euros.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Emission du 7 mars 2024","exactSourceStatus":"generic","legalStatus":"journalistic","confidence":"reported","reviewStatus":"needs_exact_source","legalReviewRequired":true,"proves":"Un bareme publie avec plafond indicatif par contrat.","publishedAt":"2026-05-02T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"La grille est tiered; afficher un plafond, pas une commission moyenne."},{"id":"selectra-self-disclosure-2024","comparator":"Selectra","supplier":null,"amountEur":null,"amountMinEur":null,"amountMaxEur":null,"amountUnit":"unknown","amountNote":"Modele declare: remuneration par fournisseur partenaire a chaque souscription; montant non publie.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"declared_model","evidenceType":"self-reported","sourceId":"selectra-methodologie","sourceIds":["selectra-methodologie"],"sourceUrl":"https://selectra.info/methodologie","sourceExcerpt":"Selectra indique etre remunere par le fournisseur partenaire pour chaque contrat souscrit.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Page methodologie","exactSourceStatus":"exact","legalStatus":"self-reported","confidence":"confirmed","reviewStatus":"reviewed","legalReviewRequired":false,"proves":"Le modele de remuneration est declare; le montant ne l'est pas.","publishedAt":"2026-05-09T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Ne confirme aucun montant actuel."},{"id":"papernest-self-disclosure-2024","comparator":"Papernest","supplier":null,"amountEur":null,"amountMinEur":null,"amountMaxEur":null,"amountUnit":"unknown","amountNote":"Modele declare: remuneration par partenaires lors des souscriptions; montant non publie.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"declared_model","evidenceType":"self-reported","sourceId":"papernest-comparateur-page","sourceIds":["papernest-comparateur-page"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.papernest.com/demarches-energie/comparateur/","sourceExcerpt":"Papernest indique que le service est finance par ses partenaires lors de souscriptions.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Page comparateur","exactSourceStatus":"exact","legalStatus":"self-reported","confidence":"confirmed","reviewStatus":"reviewed","legalReviewRequired":false,"proves":"Le modele de remuneration est declare; le montant ne l'est pas.","publishedAt":"2026-05-09T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Ne confirme aucun montant actuel."},{"id":"hellowatt-self-disclosure-2024","comparator":"Hello Watt","supplier":null,"amountEur":null,"amountMinEur":null,"amountMaxEur":null,"amountUnit":"unknown","amountNote":"Modele declare: commission a la souscription; montant non publie.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"declared_model","evidenceType":"self-reported","sourceId":"hellowatt-comparateur-faq","sourceIds":["hellowatt-comparateur-faq"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.hellowatt.fr/comparateur-fournisseurs-electricite-gaz/","sourceExcerpt":"Hello Watt declare une remuneration par fournisseur partenaire a la souscription.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"FAQ comparateur","exactSourceStatus":"exact","legalStatus":"self-reported","confidence":"confirmed","reviewStatus":"reviewed","legalReviewRequired":false,"proves":"Le modele de remuneration est declare; le montant ne l'est pas.","publishedAt":"2026-05-09T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Aucun montant public trouve dans la FAQ ou les pages legales consultees."},{"id":"choisir-self-disclosure-2024","comparator":"Choisir.com","supplier":null,"amountEur":null,"amountMinEur":null,"amountMaxEur":null,"amountUnit":"unknown","amountNote":"Modele declare: remuneration par les fournisseurs; montant non publie.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"declared_model","evidenceType":"self-reported","sourceId":"choisir-comparateur-methodologie","sourceIds":["choisir-comparateur-methodologie"],"sourceUrl":"https://www.choisir.com/energie/comparateur-electricite-gaz","sourceExcerpt":"Choisir.com indique que les fournisseurs remunerent le service de comparaison.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Page comparateur energie","exactSourceStatus":"exact","legalStatus":"self-reported","confidence":"confirmed","reviewStatus":"reviewed","legalReviewRequired":false,"proves":"Le modele de remuneration est declare; le montant ne l'est pas.","publishedAt":"2026-05-09T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Aucun montant public trouve sur la page consultee."},{"id":"mediateur-zero-commission-2024","comparator":"Mediateur national de l'energie","supplier":null,"amountEur":0,"amountMinEur":0,"amountMaxEur":0,"amountUnit":"none","amountNote":"Comparateur public officiel: aucune remuneration fournisseur.","currency":"EUR","direction":"supplier->comparator","year":2024,"evidenceSubject":"zero_commission","evidenceType":"regulator-report","sourceId":"mediateur-comparateur-mentions","sourceIds":["mediateur-comparateur-mentions"],"sourceUrl":"https://comparateur.energie-info.fr/","sourceExcerpt":"Le comparateur public indique ne recevoir aucune remuneration des fournisseurs references.","sourcePage":null,"quoteLocator":"Mentions du comparateur officiel","exactSourceStatus":"exact","legalStatus":"public-regulatory","confidence":"confirmed","reviewStatus":"reviewed","legalReviewRequired":false,"proves":"Reference publique sans flux fournisseur vers comparateur.","publishedAt":"2026-05-09T00:00:00.000Z","updatedAt":"2026-06-12T00:00:00.000Z","notes":"Point de comparaison public, pas une commission privee."}],"sources":[{"id":"complement-denquete-2024-03-07","name":"Complement d'Enquete / Revue XXI","url":"https://www.france.tv/france-2/complement-d-enquete/","type":"journalistic","authors":["Equipe Complement d'Enquete"],"publishedDate":"2024-03-07","accessedDate":"2026-05-02","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"generic","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Exact replay/article URL still to be archived; use as reported source family only."},{"id":"selectra-methodologie","name":"Methodologie des comparateurs et comparatifs - Selectra","url":"https://selectra.info/methodologie","type":"official-response","authors":["Selectra"],"publishedDate":"2024-01-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains Selectra property."},{"id":"papernest-comparateur-page","name":"Comparateur gratuit des offres electricite et gaz - papernest","url":"https://www.papernest.com/demarches-energie/comparateur/","type":"official-response","authors":["Papernest"],"publishedDate":"2024-01-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains Papernest property."},{"id":"hellowatt-comparateur-faq","name":"Comparateur Electricite et Gaz - Hello Watt FAQ","url":"https://www.hellowatt.fr/comparateur-fournisseurs-electricite-gaz/","type":"official-response","authors":["Hello Watt"],"publishedDate":"2024-01-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains Hello Watt property."},{"id":"choisir-comparateur-methodologie","name":"Comparateur electricite et gaz - Choisir.com","url":"https://www.choisir.com/energie/comparateur-electricite-gaz","type":"official-response","authors":["Choisir.com"],"publishedDate":"2024-01-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains Choisir.com property."},{"id":"mediateur-comparateur-mentions","name":"Comparateur officiel - Mediateur national de l'energie","url":"https://comparateur.energie-info.fr/","type":"regulatory","authors":["Mediateur national de l'energie"],"publishedDate":"2024-01-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"public sector information","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Public authority source."},{"id":"senat-question-03922-2025","name":"Question ecrite n. 03922 - Encadrement des comparateurs d'energie","url":"https://www.senat.fr/questions/base/2025/qSEQ250303922.html","type":"parliamentary","authors":["Senat","Ministere charge de l'industrie et de l'energie"],"publishedDate":"2025-03-27","accessedDate":"2026-06-12","license":"public sector information","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Public parliamentary record."},{"id":"ufc-comparateurs-2025","name":"Gaz et electricite - les comparateurs prives dans le collimateur","url":"https://www.quechoisir.org/actualite-gaz-et-electricite-les-comparateurs-prives-dans-le-collimateur-n149588/","type":"ngo","authors":["UFC-Que Choisir"],"publishedDate":"2025-03-05","accessedDate":"2026-06-12","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains UFC-Que Choisir property."},{"id":"ufc-selectra-sanction-2024","name":"Selectra epingle pour pratiques commerciales trompeuses","url":"https://www.quechoisir.org/actualite-comparateur-gaz-et-electricite-selectra-epingle-pour-pratiques-commerciales-trompeuses-n123586/","type":"ngo","authors":["UFC-Que Choisir"],"publishedDate":"2024-05-22","accessedDate":"2026-06-12","license":"all rights reserved","exactSourceStatus":"exact","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Short citation only; page content remains UFC-Que Choisir property."},{"id":"cre-rapport-marche-detail-2025","name":"CRE - fonctionnement des marches de detail 2023-2024","url":"https://www.cre.fr/","type":"regulatory","authors":["Commission de regulation de l'energie"],"publishedDate":"2025-11-01","accessedDate":"2026-05-09","license":"public sector information","exactSourceStatus":"generic","archiveUrl":null,"rightsNote":"Generic CRE source; exact report URL to archive before quoting further."}],"enforcementEvents":[{"id":"dgccrf-amende-selectra-2024","body":"DGCCRF","date":"2024-04","comparator":"Selectra","summary":"Amende transactionnelle de 400 000 EUR pour pratiques commerciales trompeuses. Le montant des commissions fournisseur n'est pas publie.","sourceUrl":"https://www.quechoisir.org/actualite-comparateur-gaz-et-electricite-selectra-epingle-pour-pratiques-commerciales-trompeuses-n123586/","amount":"400 000 EUR"},{"id":"dgccrf-enquete-nationale-2024","body":"DGCCRF","date":"2024","comparator":"Plusieurs comparateurs","summary":"Enquete nationale sur les intermediaires en energie citee dans la reponse gouvernementale au Senat. Resultats non publies dans le registre.","sourceUrl":"https://www.senat.fr/questions/base/2025/qSEQ250303922.html","amount":null}],"critiqueEvents":[{"id":"ufc-que-choisir-2025","body":"UFC-Que Choisir","publication":"Les comparateurs prives dans le collimateur","date":"2025-03-05","summary":"Denonce l'opacite des comparateurs prives et distingue les comparateurs independants des comparateurs commissionnes.","sourceUrl":"https://www.quechoisir.org/actualite-gaz-et-electricite-les-comparateurs-prives-dans-le-collimateur-n149588/","commissionMention":"Confirme le sujet des remunerations fournisseur-comparateur sans publier de bareme complet."},{"id":"senat-question-mars-2025","body":"Senat","publication":"Question ecrite n. 03922 - Encadrement des comparateurs d'offres de fourniture d'energie","date":"2025-03-27","summary":"Demande l'encadrement des commissions et de la transparence des comparateurs. La reponse rappelle le droit existant.","sourceUrl":"https://www.senat.fr/questions/base/2025/qSEQ250303922.html","commissionMention":"Cadre public utile, mais aucun montant de commission n'est publie."},{"id":"cre-rapport-marche-2025","body":"CRE","publication":"Rapport Fonctionnement Marches Detail 2023-2024","date":"2025-11","summary":"Contexte de marche de detail; aucune grille de commission fournisseur-comparateur identifiee.","sourceUrl":"https://www.cre.fr/","commissionMention":"Source de contexte seulement tant qu'aucun taux de commission n'est publie."}],"knownUnknowns":[{"comparator":"Hello Watt","status":"Modele commissionne declare; aucun montant public trouve.","detail":"La FAQ confirme une remuneration par fournisseur partenaire a la souscription, mais ne publie pas de montant. Les levees de fonds et communications corporate sont utiles comme contexte, pas comme preuve de commission.","checkedUrls":["https://www.hellowatt.fr/comparateur-fournisseurs-electricite-gaz/"],"checkedSourceIds":["hellowatt-comparateur-faq"],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"reviewed"},{"comparator":"LeLynx","status":"Comparateur prive multi-produits; aucun montant energie public trouve.","detail":"Les disclosures publics consultes ne detaillent pas de commission par contrat energie. Les rapports de groupe ne doivent pas etre transformes en estimation par contrat.","checkedUrls":["https://www.lelynx.fr/energie/comparateur-electricite/"],"checkedSourceIds":[],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"watching"},{"comparator":"LesFurets","status":"Comparateur prive multi-produits; aucun montant energie public trouve.","detail":"Aucune source publique identifiee ne donne une commission fournisseur-comparateur pour le segment electricite.","checkedUrls":["https://www.lesfurets.com/energie/comparateur-electricite-gaz"],"checkedSourceIds":[],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"watching"},{"comparator":"Energisme","status":"Acteur logiciel energie; pas de montant de commission residentielle trouve.","detail":"Les informations publiques relevent surtout du logiciel et de la performance energetique. Aucun bareme d'apporteur d'affaires electricite residentielle n'est documente.","checkedUrls":["https://www.energisme.com/"],"checkedSourceIds":[],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"watching"},{"comparator":"Comwatt","status":"Acteur autoconsommation/equipement; aucun bareme de commission fournisseur trouve.","detail":"Aucune source publique consultee ne documente une commission fournisseur-comparateur comparable aux comparateurs d'offres.","checkedUrls":["https://www.comwatt.com/"],"checkedSourceIds":[],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"watching"},{"comparator":"Papernest","status":"Montant publie par enquete; montant auto-declare absent.","detail":"Le plafond publie provient de l'enquete journalistique. La page officielle confirme le modele mais ne publie pas de grille.","checkedUrls":["https://www.france.tv/france-2/complement-d-enquete/","https://www.papernest.com/demarches-energie/comparateur/"],"checkedSourceIds":["complement-denquete-2024-03-07","papernest-comparateur-page"],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"needs_exact_source"},{"comparator":"Selectra","status":"Montant publie par enquete; montant actuel auto-declare absent.","detail":"Le montant de 2021 ne doit pas etre presente comme un bareme actuel. La page methodologie confirme le modele sans publier de commission.","checkedUrls":["https://www.france.tv/france-2/complement-d-enquete/","https://selectra.info/methodologie"],"checkedSourceIds":["complement-denquete-2024-03-07","selectra-methodologie"],"checkedAt":"2026-06-12","reviewStatus":"needs_exact_source"}],"monitoredComparators":["Selectra","Papernest","Hello Watt","Choisir.com","LeLynx","LesFurets","Energisme","Comwatt"],"evidenceSummary":{"publishedAmounts":2,"declaredModels":4,"zeroCommissionReferences":1,"knownUnknowns":7},"generatedAt":"2026-07-07T07:11:51.700Z","license":"CC-BY 4.0","licenseNote":"Structured Boncourant metadata is CC-BY 4.0. Short citations and source snippets remain under the rights of their original publishers.","monitoringNote":"Sources under manual watch: DGCCRF, Senat, Assemblee nationale, CRE, Mediateur national de l'energie, UFC-Que Choisir, comparator disclosures, and relevant public company disclosures. Automated monitor modules are not yet wired to stored runs."}